Germany Flexible Connection Rules Cut Battery Revenues by 29%

Key facts
- Jurisdiction
- Germany
- Instrument
- Flexible Connection Agreement
- Status
- Active
- Scope
- Two-hour and four-hour battery storage systems
- Rate or target
- Revenue reduction of 15% to 29% for two-hour systems
Anyone planning to build a new battery storage system in Germany is increasingly likely to need a flexible connection agreement (FCA) with the grid operator. However, there is no single model: agreements differ considerably between network operators and according to local grid conditions. They all have one thing in common, though: they restrict battery operation at certain times.
Until now, it has been difficult to quantify the economic impact of an FCA because each grid operator publishes its own rules, according to Christian Schäfer of the Regelleistung Online platform. He has collected the conditions imposed by eight network operators and used them to develop an FCA calculator. It estimates the impact on two-hour and four-hour battery systems operating in wholesale electricity and balancing markets.
For two-hour systems, the FCA conditions imposed by N-Ergie reduce revenues by 15%. Under Bayernwerk’s agreements, the reduction reaches 29%, according to Regelleistung Online. Schäfer also calculated the impact on four-hour systems, for which estimated revenue losses range from 11% to 20%. Users can also enter their own assumptions into the calculator.
Schäfer says that although the models differ in detail between network operators, their underlying structures are largely similar. They generally impose a restricted power band when nearby solar and wind installations are generating substantial amounts of electricity. Other common provisions include maximum power gradients, limits on balancing capacity and rules governing how close to real time an operating schedule can be changed.
The permitted power band specified in an FCA is a major factor affecting revenues. Network operators often use reference installations as a benchmark. Depending on weather forecasts, they estimate how much a typical solar or wind installation would generate and use that figure to determine how much electricity a battery can feed into the grid.
Bayernwerk uses a straightforward linear restriction, while SH Netz sets a threshold at 50% of forecast solar and wind generation. Below that level, batteries face no restrictions. Above it, permitted discharge capacity decreases linearly. When solar and wind generation reaches 100% of the reference output, battery discharge is reduced to zero.
Bayernwerk applies this approach earlier and considers solar generation only. Battery discharge is restricted once solar output reaches 30% of the reference level and prohibited entirely at 60%. As a result, the restrictions mainly affect midday operation from spring through autumn.
Charging restrictions work in the opposite direction, Schäfer explains. When solar and wind generation falls below a specified threshold, batteries are allowed to charge only at reduced power. SH Netz and Bayernwerk set this threshold at 10%, while Mitnetz uses 20%. Between 11 p.m. and 5 a.m., a minimum level of grid import remains available. At Bayernwerk, this amounts to 40% of the battery’s power capacity.
Other restrictions are based on different parameters. N-Ergie uses a simplified model that limits charging and discharging during fixed time windows, which also vary by season. This approach does not account for actual grid congestion and gives battery operators no additional operating flexibility when the network could accommodate it.
EWE Netz, by contrast, uses a model that restricts charging following a call during the hours of highest grid demand, for a maximum of 800 hours per year.
Almost all network operators also specify power gradients in their FCAs, limiting how quickly output at the grid connection point can change. The usual requirement is 6% of installed capacity per minute. This means a battery needs almost 17 minutes to move from zero to full power, while switching from full charging to full discharge takes more than half an hour.
EWE Netz is more permissive, Schäfer says. It adopts the value in the nationwide standard wording for Technical Connection Rules (TAB): 0.37% per second, equivalent to slightly more than 22% per minute.
The 6% gradient limit is particularly restrictive in the day-ahead and intraday markets. Without this constraint, batteries could capture price fluctuations within individual 15-minute trading periods. With the gradient limit, they cannot complete full power changes within a quarter-hour. Regelleistung Online estimates that a gradient of 6% per minute reduces wholesale market revenues by about 2.5%. For 2026, the estimated loss was just under 3%.
The gradient restriction can also affect balancing services. SH Netz and Bayernwerk explicitly refer to secondary control reserve in their standard contracts. This effectively determines the maximum capacity that a battery can prequalify to provide, as the full contracted response must be delivered within five minutes. At a gradient of 6% per minute, a battery can reach only 30% of its rated power within that period. Most network operators set the same 30% limit for secondary control reserve.
The rules for primary control reserve vary more widely, according to Schäfer. SH Netz and Bayernwerk exclude it, while Mitnetz and LEW allow up to 25% of installed capacity.
For operating schedules, SH Netz, Bayernwerk and Mitnetz require notifications 60 minutes before delivery. These can still be adjusted up to five minutes before delivery, provided there is no grid congestion. LEW only requires schedules to be submitted in advance.
EWE Netz is considerably stricter. It freezes schedules 2.5 hours before delivery, after which batteries may deviate by only plus or minus 25% of their rated power. This leaves little room for short-term intraday trading, Schäfer says.
Key calculations
Regelleistung Online applied the various restrictions to a 1 MW battery with either 2 MWh or 4 MWh of storage capacity, operating at 1.5 cycles per day and with an efficiency of 90%. The assumed marketing strategy prioritizes balancing services and the day-ahead market, followed by the intraday auction and, finally, continuous intraday trading.
The calculations compare operation with and without restrictions. Market data for November and December 2026 was not yet available and was extrapolated. Weather conditions and wind and solar generation were based on reference values for the respective locations.
The results show that revenue losses are generally lower for four-hour batteries. Restrictions on balancing services have a particularly significant impact. Regelleistung Online estimates that, on average, around three-quarters of the total revenue loss is attributable to limits on balancing capacity.
<em>Image: FCA calculator ranking, Regelleistung Online. Revenue breakdown for a 1 MW/2 MWh battery under Bayernwerk’s FCA conditions, covering wholesale and balancing markets in 2026.</em>
Schäfer also points to a potential shift in the revenue mix. While many battery systems currently rely mainly on balancing services, he expects their share of total revenues to decline as more storage capacity enters the market. By 2030, he forecasts that around 80% of battery revenues will come from wholesale electricity trading, with balancing services accounting for the remaining 20%.
Under these simplified assumptions, the impact of an FCA would be considerably smaller because wholesale trading is less affected by the restrictions than balancing services, Schäfer says. Across the seven distribution system operators included in the comparison, an FCA would reduce revenues for a two-hour battery by around 10% in 2030, compared with just under 23% in 2026.
The main sources of revenue losses are also expected to change. Restrictions on balancing capacity, currently by far the largest factor, would account for an average loss of only 3.5% in 2030. Power band and gradient restrictions would together account for slightly more than 5%, becoming the more significant constraints.
Developers can use the FCA calculator to estimate how individual network operators’ requirements could affect their storage projects. The results should be treated as indicative, however, because some inputs are based on reference data and the calculations do not account for additional interventions by network operators during periods of grid congestion.
Pvola take
The lack of a standard model forces developers to navigate a patchwork of local rules that significantly erode project economics. Bayernwerk’s early solar-based restrictions specifically target midday operation, the highest-value arbitrage window. This fragmentation increases transaction costs and complicates financing for storage assets.
Frequently asked questions
How much can flexible connection agreements reduce revenues for two-hour battery systems in Germany?
Flexible connection agreements can reduce revenues by up to 29% for two-hour battery systems. This maximum reduction is observed under the specific conditions imposed by Bayernwerk, according to Regelleistung Online.
What is the estimated revenue impact of flexible connection agreements on four-hour battery systems in Germany?
The estimated revenue loss for four-hour battery systems ranges from 11% to 20% under flexible connection agreements. These figures are derived from a calculator that analyzes conditions set by eight different German network operators.
Why is the 6% gradient limit in German technical connection rules particularly restrictive for battery storage operators?
The 6% gradient limit prevents batteries from completing full power changes within 15-minute trading periods. This restriction limits the ability of storage assets to capture price fluctuations in day-ahead and intraday markets.